It seems like after I customize my site (with the front end theme editor, not editing any files) the force login and hide admin bar options stop working. The first few times, going to theme options and toggling them off and on fixed the issues. This time it’s not. I’ve also tried uninstalling the Restrict my Site plugin, but that didn’t work either.
When I log out or open the site in an incognito window, I can see my homepage with the admin bar asking me to log in. For some reason it’s also showing the BuddyApp logo/mini logo and half the time the main menu background is white. When I login, it takes me back to my homepage and everything is correct. Correct logo, no admin bar, etc.