Hi there,
Today I found a bug that make all my afternoon in searching answers in the net, so I was almost giving up and was think in deactivate all the plugins and test if some of them where cause this issue.
The issue is: inside the topic, there where several replies, and I had configured in “Forum” to create page when there was 10 replies. But that was not happening, the topic… went and went, without creating page for the several replies that existe.
But just 10 minutes ago I found out in the web that someone discover a bug in bbpress forums. This bug is that if you activate the “Replying Threading” it will stop creating page.
So you only can have or the “replying threading” and don’t have pagination for you replies.
Or you can have you pagination for the replies and cannot have the “replying threading”.
So I deactivate this and now look nice.
Hope me sharing this with you will help others that will have the same issue.